An airy ivory sitting room with tall French windows overlooking a private lawn and mature late-autumn trees in Brookville.

Brookville New Construction, Priced Against the Houses Around It

12 Quaker Ridge Drive is a brick center-hall colonial, built in 2025, at the end of a cul-de-sac on two acres in Brookville. It has two quartz waterfall islands, a Wolf six-burner range and a curved oak staircase. Its OneKey MLS record shows five asking prices since May 23, 2026: $6,299,999, then $6,199,999 on the same day, $5,999,999 on July 6, $5,799,999 on September 2 and $5,599,999 on October 1. That is $700,000 off the first ask, about 11 percent, in a little over four months.

The house is new and well built, and it has gone more than 450 days on OneKey's website as of mid-November. It is not alone. This fall, Brookville's prices have been set mostly by its two-acre lots. Older houses on those lots are closing near asking price. The new houses on the same lots are still adjusting downward and have not yet sold for the premium their first asks assumed.

The lot is doing the pricing

209 Brookville Road shows what an older Brookville house is worth today. Douglas Elliman's record shows it sold for $4,200,000. It is a 5,662-square-foot house built in 1955 on 2.2166 acres, with a pool, sport court, cabana-style pavilion and a wraparound porch. That works out to roughly $742 a square foot for a house about 70 years old.

That sale fits the rest of the season. Other Brookville closings from late August through October 2026 were mostly older houses on about two acres. Several sold between roughly $3.4 million and $4.4 million, and a few closed nearer $2.5 million. Most closed within a few percent of their final ask. 11 Wenwood Drive, built in 1958, closed above its $3,299,000 ask at $3,380,000.

When a 1950s house on two acres sells for more than $4 million, most of that money is paying for the land: the acreage, the setback from the road and the fact that Brookville has so little vacant land to build on. The house matters, but it is the smaller part of the price. A new house has to earn its premium above that land value, and this fall the asks show how hard that has been.

New construction, measured by the square foot

Here are Brookville's current new-construction listings, with the two older houses that just went on the market and the 1955 sale for reference. The figures are from OneKey MLS and Douglas Elliman records as of each page's last update in fall 2026. The per-square-foot numbers are simple division.

Property Built Lot Price, fall 2026 Sq ft Approx. per sq ft
209 Brookville Rd 1955 2.22 acres $4,200,000 sold 5,662 $742
30 Evans Dr 2025 2.00 acres $7,988,000 ask 11,400 total $700
14 Wenwood Dr 2026, completion est. Summer 2027 2.00 acres $6,399,999 ask 7,200 $890
12 Quaker Ridge Dr 2025 2.00 acres $5,599,999 ask not stated n/a
30 Wood Acres Rd 2020 2.53 acres $7,950,000 ask 7,325 $1,085
25 Old Wheatley Rd 2006 2.54 acres $8,250,000 ask 7,396 $1,115

These figures are only a rough comparison, because listings measure square footage differently. The 30 Evans Drive record gives about 11,400 square feet of total living space, and that includes a 3,600-square-foot walk-out lower level. Counting only the roughly 7,800 square feet above the lower level, the ask is about $1,020 a foot. The 209 Brookville Road listing describes a finished lower level, but the record doesn't say whether its 5,662 square feet include it.

Even with that caveat, the pattern is clear. On its own total, a 2025 house in the Broad Hollow section with a 65-foot pool, radiant heat and a retractable glass wall is asking about what a 1955 house just sold for per square foot. On the stricter measure, its premium over the older house is about a third, well below what the size and finish of a new house would suggest.

How the asks have come down

The new houses started higher. 30 Evans Drive was listed at $8,750,000 on April 11, 2026. It went to $8,350,000 on August 22 and to $7,988,000 on October 15, $762,000 below the first ask. 12 Quaker Ridge Drive went through the five steps described above.

Both houses are in Brookville but carry Glen Head mailing addresses, because ZIP code 11545 covers both. Buyers searching by town name can miss them.

The pace matters as much as the cuts. Across Nassau County in the third quarter of 2026, single-family homes spent a median of 39 days on market. Sellers received 100.5 percent of original list price, and the county had 3.3 months of supply, according to OneKey MLS's Q3-2026 Nassau County report, with data as of October 7, 2026. A Brookville new build that is still listed after 200 or 450 days is moving at a different pace from the county. Most of that gap comes from buyers here declining to pay for new construction at the first ask while they wait to see whether it comes down.

The cuts have been small and frequent, roughly $100,000 to $400,000 at a time. A price that comes down in small steps tends to settle near where buyers already value the land plus a reasonable house. At 209 Brookville Road, that level was about $4.2 million for 2.2 acres and a well-kept 1955 house.

Where buyers have paid more, and what it was for

The two highest per-square-foot asks in the village belong to houses that aren't new. 30 Wood Acres Road, completed in 2020, went on the market November 4, 2026 at $7,950,000 for 7,325 square feet on 2.53 acres. 25 Old Wheatley Road, a 2006 European-inspired estate, has been listed since October 5 at $8,250,000 for 7,396 square feet on 2.54 acres. Both ask more than $1,000 a square foot, and both are on lots a third of an acre or more larger than the two-acre parcels under the 2025 builds.

These are asking prices, and this winter will show whether they hold. Even so, they show what Brookville sellers think buyers will pay extra for. It is extra land, established landscaping and a finished estate setting, not the age of the house. A house completed in 2020 on 2.5 acres and a house completed in 2025 on 2 acres are both modern, and the house on the larger lot is asking more per square foot on either measure of 30 Evans Drive.

14 Wenwood Drive is the earliest test of the same idea. It is a 7,200-square-foot new home on 2.004 acres with completion estimated for Summer 2027, listed at $6,399,999 since April 23, 2026. At about $890 a foot, it is priced between the 1955 sale and the established-estate asks. A buyer who commits before completion can choose finishes while the house is being built, and that is part of what the price covers.

What this means for a buyer and for a builder

For a buyer weighing a new house against an older one, the land costs about the same in either case. 209 Brookville Road and 30 Evans Drive sit on almost the same amount of land, roughly two acres each. What differs is the house: its age, its systems, its layout and the years of work that would go into renovating the older one. A new build's ask is fair when the gap between it and a comparable older house on similar land is close to what it would cost to bring that older house up to the same standard. The fall 2026 price cuts suggest Brookville buyers are making that calculation, and the new-build asks have been coming down toward it. Our notes on which Brookville upgrades add value cover the renovation side of that comparison.

For a builder, the useful number is what an older house on a comparable lot sells for, because that sets the lower end of the market for the land. The land price is close to fixed. Builders can control the house, and this fall's listing histories suggest the premium for a finished new house in Brookville is narrower than the first asks of spring 2026 assumed. Supply is tight on its own terms. Earlier this fall we covered why Brookville's Tam O'Shanter went back to golf instead of becoming 27 estate lots, which keeps new two-acre parcels scarce. Scarce land supports the price of the lot more than the price of the house built on it.

A seller of an older house can take some reassurance from 209 Brookville Road. A well-kept 1955 house on two acres, priced realistically, sold at a per-square-foot price that a brand-new house nearby is still trying to reach. Our home valuation starts from the lot, and the Brookville neighborhood page has the wider village context.

If you are deciding whether to build, buy new or buy an older Brookville house and improve it, Dalia Elison can compare the costs with you, drawing on her years of construction and new-construction advisory work. Schedule a Confidential Consultation.

Connect with Dalia

For expert guidance and personalized attention in real estate contact Dalia.

Follow Me on Instagram