"The owners at the time just let the application lapse, so that fell apart," Brookville Mayor Daniel Serota told Newsday in August 2026, describing the housing plan for the 148-acre former Tam O'Shanter Club. That plan already had preliminary subdivision approval. The design complied with village zoning, the land was inside one of the most supply-constrained estate markets on Long Island, and the developer had paid $11.8 million for the property in 2019, according to Newsday. The topsoil stopped it. On September 30, 2026, the village announced that the property had been sold to Armchair Collective, which plans to restore the course as a members-only, for-profit private golf club.
Anyone weighing Brookville against neighboring estate villages should see what happened here as a pricing story. On former golf land, residential use carries a cleanup bill that golf use does not. When that bill is large enough, the cheapest future for the land is the course it already was.
The Approval That Could Not Be Built
Here is the sequence, taken from village records, state filings and local reporting:
- 1962. Tam O'Shanter opens. Robert Trent Jones Sr. remodels it in 1968, and David Postlethwait redesigns it in 1999.
- January 29, 2019. Titan Tam, LLC and Segme Tam LLC take ownership. Club operations other than golf had already stopped by 2018.
- Summer 2021. Golf ends.
- March 16, 2022. The Planning Board grants preliminary approval for 29 lots. Twenty-seven are for single-family homes averaging 5 acres, one holds a stormwater recharge basin, and one goes to the village for municipal use.
- August 2023. The New York State Department of Environmental Conservation logs a Brownfield Cleanup Program application for "Grandview Estates," site C130252, at 74 Fruitledge Road.
- October 29, 2025. Brookville holds a public hearing on a code amendment that would allow for-profit golf clubs.
- September 30, 2026. The sale to Armchair Collective is announced.
The deal stalled between steps four and five. The approval came with a condition: the Nassau County Department of Health had to certify that the soil was safe for people to live on, according to Long Island Press. After more than 200 test borings, the department found elevated arsenic tied to the property's decades as a golf course. For homes to go forward, it required removing about 135,000 cubic yards of soil and replacing it with clean topsoil.
Village officials estimated that removal at roughly 11,000 dump-truck round trips over about a year, plus thousands more trucks bringing clean soil in. The trucks would enter opposite Tappentown Lane and leave by Route 107. The Department of Health would not allow the work to be done in stages. Village Attorney John M. Chase put the total at about 23,000 truckloads and called the method "draconian," pointing to the noise, the emissions and the damage to village roads.
Why the Same Soil Works Under a Fairway
The soil data explain why the cost lands on residential use alone. Consultants at VHB took about 200 soil borings in February 2022, working with the county health department, and measured them against a residential cleanup objective of 16 mg/kg for arsenic, according to the NYS DEC soil impacts summary. One shallow sample came back at 82.9 mg/kg. In the top three inches, 66 percent of tested samples exceeded residential standards for arsenic, cadmium or mercury. The rate fell to 52 percent at 10 to 12 inches and 10 percent at 12 to 24 inches.
The contamination sits near the surface and is concentrated in the fairways. The property's perimeter was expected to stay largely untouched. At the March 2024 town hall, residents were told that if the land stayed a golf course, the arsenic would not be a hazard because it is bound in the soil. At that point, keeping the golf course was not under consideration.
The developer tried to lower the cost. State Senator Jack Martins, appearing as private counsel, presented a second option. Instead of hauling the soil out, crews would mill or till it in place, grid by grid, with village consultants checking each section. He said the applicant had been approved for state brownfield tax credits to offset removal costs. Residents at the meeting were uneasy with either approach. The application later lapsed.
So the land had a known, expensive gap between its zoning and what it would take to build under that zoning. Twenty-seven estate lots required a full cleanup to residential standards. An 18-hole course required none of that work to keep operating.
What the 2025 Code Change Did
Golf was the cheaper use, but Brookville's code had limited who could run a club. At the October 2025 hearing, the village described the amendment as adding for-profit clubs to the permitted conditional uses in residential districts. It would also set rules for accessory structures within a golf club. Its stated purpose was "to encourage the preservation of golf courses" and the open space they hold. The village later said restrictions in the earlier code had discouraged golf course developers interested in Tam. Serota told Newsday the village "tweaked" its zoning to encourage a buyer to keep the property as a course.
The amendment did nothing to the soil. It changed who could bid on the land. Once a for-profit operator could own and run the course, someone could value the property as a working golf asset that never needed residential cleanup. Armchair Collective describes itself as a national private-golf membership connecting architecturally exceptional courses, with access by invitation and membership nominations to open in fall 2026. In his September 2026 message, Serota called the outcome "welcome news." He said land "that might otherwise have been lost to residential development will now remain as open space."
The village also said any redevelopment will still go through environmental, planning and regulatory review. Its announcement does not say the earlier environmental concerns have been resolved, and it gives no purchase price, renovation schedule or reopening date.
One Village Over, the Same Question Is Still Open
Old Brookville has a closed club of similar age facing the same cleanup question. The former Cedarbrook Club opened in 1961, and Triple Gold Development has proposed homes for it under the name Royal Peninsula.
| Tam O'Shanter, Brookville | Cedarbrook Club, Old Brookville | |
|---|---|---|
| Acreage | About 148 | 125.19 |
| Residential plan | 27 homes, about 5-acre average | 31 lots, 3-acre minimum |
| Soil findings | Arsenic and other metals above residential standards | Some metals and pesticide compounds above residential standards |
| Current path | Sold to a private golf operator, September 2026 | SEQRA review; the January 15, 2026 hearing record says a DEIS is required |
Cedarbrook's draft scope says sampling ordered by NYSDEC in 2025 found shallow soil exceeding residential standards. The draft scope says those areas will have to be investigated and remediated, according to the Old Brookville draft environmental impact statement. The list of required approvals includes a Brownfield Cleanup Program Certificate of Completion. At the January hearing, one speaker said removing contaminated soil "dump truck after dump truck" would be very disruptive. Royal Peninsula is the same test Tam faced, now going through the environmental review process. How its DEIS handles cut, fill and truck trips will show what a residential conversion of former club land costs on the North Shore today.
What This Means for Estate Supply
Brookville's own summary of its zoning describes a minimum of two acres per residential property. With minimums like that, a single closed golf course is one of the few places large enough for a builder to add a group of new estate homes at once. Tam would have produced 27 new homes averaging 5 acres, in a village where new construction usually comes one teardown at a time. Those homes are no longer coming.
Meanwhile, demand at the top of the market has been rising. In the first half of 2026, homes selling for $2 million or more made up a 12.9 percent larger share of Nassau and Suffolk sales than a year earlier, according to Newsday. That count includes the East End. In June 2026, homes at that level sold at a median of $2.7 million after a median of 23 days on market. The broader market is also tight. OneKey MLS reported 3.6 months of supply across its service area in August 2026, and Nassau's single-family median that month was $911,000, up 4.7 percent from a year earlier. None of these figures is specific to Brookville. Together they describe a market where 27 new lots would have arrived to steady demand.
The effects split by situation. Buyers looking for a newly built home on several acres in Brookville should plan around resales and individual rebuilds, since Tam will not add a new subdivision. Owners along Fruitledge Road, Glenby Lane, Tappentown Lane, Delray Drive and Hip Point Court, the streets named in the site's planning materials, now sit next to land planned for renovation as a private course, not a year of soil hauling followed by home construction. For developers, Tam shows that an acre of former fairway can carry a large remediation cost, and that cost should be known before an offer, not discovered after approval.
A Few Straight Answers
Has Tam O'Shanter reopened? No. The village's September 2026 announcement gives no renovation schedule or reopening date.
What did the 2019 buyers pay? Accounts differ. Newsday reported $11.8 million. A 2024 Long Island Press story cited $15 million, attributing that figure to the village newsletter.
Has the soil been cleaned up? The public record does not say so. The DEC notice confirms a brownfield application was received. The 2026 sale announcement says any work faces further environmental review and does not say the earlier concerns have been resolved.
Tam O'Shanter turned on site history that the zoning map never showed. Before you buy land on the Gold Coast, price a new build, or sell near a parcel that is changing use, it helps to have an advisor who reads soil reports and planning transcripts alongside comparable sales. Dalia Elison brings construction and development experience to exactly these questions. Schedule a Confidential Consultation to talk through what a nearby land-use change could mean for your property or your next purchase.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.